Hull comedian Lucy Beaumont confessed during exit interviews that deciphering deceit inside Ardross Castle was “harder than parenting a toddler on tour”. Chortle reports she expected obvious nervous tics but found seasoned performers maintained perfect composure, leaving her reliant on gut instinct that often misfired.
Beaumont’s self deprecating humour initially endeared her to the group, yet she revealed to The Sun that constant second guessing triggered sleepless nights, forcing her to request lavender oil from production. She described breakfast reveals as “jump scares without the soundtrack” where every smile might mask betrayal.
Despite comedy roots, Beaumont tried analytical tools, drawing Venn diagrams on napkins to track vote patterns. However, shifting alliances rendered diagrams obsolete within hours. Radiotimes analysts comparing footage say her visible frustration became fodder for Traitors keen to redirect suspicion.​
Viewers sympathised. Hashtag #ProtectLucy trended on launch night, generating over 900,000 X impressions. Yet sympathy offered no game protection, and Beaumont acknowledged that faith in kindness is a liability where rules reward ruthlessness.
Talking after the elimination, she mused that comedy audiences present honest feedback through laughter, whereas castle residents perform layered personas. The lesson, she says, is that punchlines are easy when compared with poker faces.